Scotland's World Cup hopes are hanging in the balance after a crushing defeat to Argentina at Murrayfield. The once-formidable team, who had been touted as being on the cusp of something special under coach Gregor Townsend, have shown that they can be thoroughly exposed when their opponents seize the initiative.
The 21-0 lead which Scotland built up against a Pumas side in obvious distress was a stunning demonstration of just how far off the mark this team is. The great teams, those that consistently produce results on the biggest stages, manage to take control of games early and never look back. Scotland, however, were unable to capitalise on their advantage and instead allowed Argentina to mount an epic comeback.
The turning point came when a long looping pass from Finn Russell was picked off by the Pumas, allowing them to break free downfield. This was followed by Blair Kinghorn's send-off for illegally halting an attack, which handed the game back to Argentina on a silver platter. Julian Montoya's subsequent try was just the beginning of a 18-minute spell in which Scotland completely capitulated.
It is this inability to handle the momentum swing at crucial moments that has become the hallmark of this team under Townsend. The problems that have cropped up again and again, from creating opportunities but not converting them, to running big teams close but ultimately falling short, are ones that it seems as though they will never quite shake off.
Townsend's comments that his side lacks the mentality required to win the biggest games rings hollow when you consider their abysmal record in such situations. The two World Cup pool games against Ireland in 2019 and 2023 remain fresh in the mind, a stark reminder of just how far they have to go if they are to truly compete at the highest level.
For now, the team's progress is stuck in limbo. The question on everyone's lips is whether this team will ever take that next step and deliver on their potential. For those fans who have been loudly booing them from the Murrayfield pitch, it may be tempting to wonder if someone else might do a better job.
The 21-0 lead which Scotland built up against a Pumas side in obvious distress was a stunning demonstration of just how far off the mark this team is. The great teams, those that consistently produce results on the biggest stages, manage to take control of games early and never look back. Scotland, however, were unable to capitalise on their advantage and instead allowed Argentina to mount an epic comeback.
The turning point came when a long looping pass from Finn Russell was picked off by the Pumas, allowing them to break free downfield. This was followed by Blair Kinghorn's send-off for illegally halting an attack, which handed the game back to Argentina on a silver platter. Julian Montoya's subsequent try was just the beginning of a 18-minute spell in which Scotland completely capitulated.
It is this inability to handle the momentum swing at crucial moments that has become the hallmark of this team under Townsend. The problems that have cropped up again and again, from creating opportunities but not converting them, to running big teams close but ultimately falling short, are ones that it seems as though they will never quite shake off.
Townsend's comments that his side lacks the mentality required to win the biggest games rings hollow when you consider their abysmal record in such situations. The two World Cup pool games against Ireland in 2019 and 2023 remain fresh in the mind, a stark reminder of just how far they have to go if they are to truly compete at the highest level.
For now, the team's progress is stuck in limbo. The question on everyone's lips is whether this team will ever take that next step and deliver on their potential. For those fans who have been loudly booing them from the Murrayfield pitch, it may be tempting to wonder if someone else might do a better job.