Labour's new welfare changes are practical and compassionate – so why not loudly say so? | Polly Toynbee

Labour's New Welfare Changes: A Mixed Bag of Progress and Opportunity for Improvement

The Labour government has taken steps to address the long-standing issues in the welfare system, and while some progress has been made, there is still much work to be done.

Reversing decades of cuts to benefits is a significant achievement, but it is also a missed opportunity to highlight the positive impact that these changes will have on vulnerable members of society. Rather than being celebrated as a victory for Labour's compassionate policies, the government seems hesitant to trumpet its successes in reversing the worst excesses of the Tory era.

Stephen Timms, the Minister for Social Security and Disability, has been instrumental in driving forward many of these reforms. As he pointed out during an "in conversation" session at the Fabian thinktank conference, reducing child poverty is what Labour governments do best. The new universal credit standard allowance will rise above inflation every year for four years, which may seem like a small step but will make a positive difference in the lives of those who rely on it.

One significant change that Timms has championed is the removal of the two-child limit, which has been shown to be behind one of the greatest ever falls in child poverty. The Joseph Rowntree Foundation reported this week that Labour's policy changes are paying off, with 450,000 children set to be lifted out of poverty and an additional 100,000 benefiting from free school meals.

However, despite these successes, there is still a lingering sense that the government is struggling to articulate its vision for the welfare system. Timms acknowledged that the "rising" benefit bill has been a talking point for the Tories, but he stressed that this is a misconception and that the proportion of GDP spent on working-age benefits has remained at 4-5% for decades.

The future jobs fund, which was introduced during the financial crisis, is also being revived as part of Labour's youth guarantee. Work coaches will be trained to provide support to young people who are neither in work nor education, rather than simply punishing them with sanctions.

Ultimately, the key to securing progress on these issues is for the government to change the narrative around benefits and welfare. Rather than allowing the right-wing media to portray those receiving benefits as "scroungers" or "skivers", Labour needs to promote a more nuanced understanding of the complex issues at play.

By highlighting the positive impact that well-designed benefit systems can have, particularly on young people who are struggling to make ends meet in a post-Covid generation, Labour can begin to shift public attitudes and build a more compassionate welfare system.
 
I'm totally down with reversing those decades of cuts to benefits 🤩, like it's about time we started treating our most vulnerable citizens with some decent dignity. But, on the other hand, isn't it just a bit weird that they're being all secretive about celebrating their own achievements? Like, don't get me wrong, I'm happy they're addressing long-standing issues and all, but come on, can't they just be proud of themselves for once? 🤷‍♀️

And, oh man, the universal credit standard allowance rising above inflation every year is a small step in the right direction, I guess. But what's with the 'small step' business? Are we not worthy of better than that? 😒 It's only a matter of time before we're talking about actual significant changes and not just incremental improvements.

I'm loving the removal of the two-child limit though - it's about time someone acknowledged that having more kids shouldn't be a reason to punish families for needing support. And, yeah, 450,000 kids lifted out of poverty is no joke 🎉... but what about the rest? We still have so many people struggling.

Work coaches being trained to support young people who are neither in work nor education sounds like a solid plan, I suppose. But, seriously, why do we need 'youth guarantee' programs? Can't we just provide more opportunities and resources for people to get back on their feet without needing all these fancy programs? 🤔
 
I think its a shame theyre not trumpeting those reversals of Tory cuts more, i mean, 450k kids lifted outta poverty is a big deal 🤩. But yeah, the gov doesnt seem to be articulating their vision for welfare that well. They need to shift the narrative around benefits and welfare, stop gettin painted as scroungers by the right-wing media. Its all about nuance and understanding that its not just one-size-fits-all 👍
 
I think it's awesome they're reversing those decades of cuts to benefits 🤩! It's like a weight's been lifted off the shoulders of so many people who've been struggling to make ends meet. And I love that Stephen Timms is championing these reforms, he seems like a real stand-up guy 🙌. The fact that child poverty rates are dropping and 450k kids will be lifted out of poverty is just incredible 💪! Now, let's talk about the future jobs fund – it's like a safety net for young people who are trying to figure out their lives 😊. I think Labour needs to own this narrative and show the public that benefits aren't something to be ashamed of, but rather a way to support people in need 💡. And can we please talk about how these reforms will benefit mental health too? 🤝
 
🤔 I'm not sure I agree with this one. The government is still being pretty cagey about the changes they're making to the welfare system, especially when it comes to touting their successes. I mean, 450k kids being lifted out of poverty sounds awesome, but where's the big celebration? It feels like Labour just wants everyone to think "oh yeah, we fixed things" without really explaining how or why these changes were needed in the first place.

And let's be real, it's still not perfect. The removal of the two-child limit is a great start, but what about all the other issues that are still plaguing families? Single parents struggling to make ends meet, for example. I'm just not sure we're seeing enough from Labour on these fronts.

I think the key to getting progress on this stuff is actually having a more nuanced conversation about welfare, like you said. But it's gotta be more than just some PR spin – Labour needs to actually show us what they're working on and how they plan to tackle these issues head-on. 📊
 
The platform is still so slow to update 🙄... been trying to comment for like 10 mins but it just keeps saying "loading" 😒. anyway, about these new labour changes... its good that they're reversing those cuts to benefits, but can we get some real info on how much more money is actually being put back into the system? 🤑 all this talk of rising above inflation every year for four years sounds nice, but what's the actual number looking at? 📊 and what about the rest of us who aren't eligible for universal credit? 💸
 
the labour government's new welfare changes are a mixed bag 🤔 - some progress has been made, like reversing those tory-era cuts to benefits, which is a good step forward 👍. but it feels like they're being too quiet about the impact this will have on vulnerable people. i think steve timms and labour should be shouting from the rooftops about how these changes are gonna make a difference in reducing child poverty 📈.

also, removing the two-child limit is a big win 💪. it's great to see that 450k kids are set to be lifted out of poverty and another 100k getting free school meals 🍔🏫. but we need to hear more about how they plan to make this happen and what other changes are coming down the pipeline.

one thing that really bothers me is when politicians say things like "the benefit bill has been rising" without explaining why 🤷‍♀️. it's not just a numbers game - it's about people's lives. we need to get behind labour on this, but also hold them accountable for what they're doing.
 
Back
Top