Federal Judge Hands Mangione a Reprieve: Death Penalty Off the Table for Fatal Shooting of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson.
In a move that has breathed new life into the case against Luigi Mangione, U.S. District Judge Margaret M. Garnett ruled on Friday to dismiss two federal counts against the 27-year-old accused killer. These counts were murder through use of a firearm and a related firearms offense, both of which carried the potential for a death sentence.
The decision leaves Mangione facing only two federal stalking counts, carrying a maximum sentence of life in prison without parole. Mangione has pleaded not guilty to all charges.
In her ruling, Judge Garnett deemed the murder charge technically flawed, as it can only be applied when used in conjunction with a "crime of violence." She disagreed with prosecutors' argument that Mangione's alleged stalking of Thompson met this standard.
The judge's decision was met with praise from Mangione's attorneys, who described it as an "incredible decision" and expressed relief on behalf of their client. The ruling has been hailed by Mangione's supporters, who view him as a folk hero who took a stand against the for-profit health insurance industry that they claim wronged Thompson.
Thompson, 50, was shot outside a Manhattan hotel in December 2024, sparking a manhunt across the region. Mangione is accused of gunning down Thompson as he was heading to an early morning investor conference.
The judge also ruled that Mangione's federal trial can feature evidence seized from his backpack when he was arrested at a McDonald's restaurant in Pennsylvania on December 9, 2024. The authorities found a ghost gun, fake IDs, and writings detailing Mangione's grievances against the private healthcare system.
In April, Attorney General Pam Bondi directed prosecutors to seek the death penalty against Mangione, marking the Justice Department's first attempt to do so during President Donald Trump's second term.
In a move that has breathed new life into the case against Luigi Mangione, U.S. District Judge Margaret M. Garnett ruled on Friday to dismiss two federal counts against the 27-year-old accused killer. These counts were murder through use of a firearm and a related firearms offense, both of which carried the potential for a death sentence.
The decision leaves Mangione facing only two federal stalking counts, carrying a maximum sentence of life in prison without parole. Mangione has pleaded not guilty to all charges.
In her ruling, Judge Garnett deemed the murder charge technically flawed, as it can only be applied when used in conjunction with a "crime of violence." She disagreed with prosecutors' argument that Mangione's alleged stalking of Thompson met this standard.
The judge's decision was met with praise from Mangione's attorneys, who described it as an "incredible decision" and expressed relief on behalf of their client. The ruling has been hailed by Mangione's supporters, who view him as a folk hero who took a stand against the for-profit health insurance industry that they claim wronged Thompson.
Thompson, 50, was shot outside a Manhattan hotel in December 2024, sparking a manhunt across the region. Mangione is accused of gunning down Thompson as he was heading to an early morning investor conference.
The judge also ruled that Mangione's federal trial can feature evidence seized from his backpack when he was arrested at a McDonald's restaurant in Pennsylvania on December 9, 2024. The authorities found a ghost gun, fake IDs, and writings detailing Mangione's grievances against the private healthcare system.
In April, Attorney General Pam Bondi directed prosecutors to seek the death penalty against Mangione, marking the Justice Department's first attempt to do so during President Donald Trump's second term.
. Now he's only facing life in prison for stalking Thompson, not murder or death penalty 
. Judge M. Garnett said the murder charge was technically flawed because it needs to be part of a "crime of violence"... like duh! 
Anyway, Mangione's lawyers are stoked and claim he took on the insurance industry that wronged Thompson 
. Not sure what's true in this story, but one thing's for sure: Mangione's gonna get a fair trial now 
Man, this whole situation just goes to show that we gotta be careful about jumpin' to conclusions, ya know? I mean, Mangione was accused of somethin' pretty serious, and it seemed like he was facin' the noose. But then this judge comes along and says, "Hold up, let's take a closer look." And guess what? She finds some flaws in the case that might just set him free.
. Two federal counts down means he's got a lot of breathing room now. It's crazy how some people get labeled as "folk heroes" just 'cause they took a stand against big corporations 
. For all we know, Mangione was just a dude who lost his family to high healthcare costs and snapped 
.
, but I guess Judge Garnett saw through that 
. Still, this reprieve gives him a chance to make some sense of things maybe? Maybe he'll get help for his issues or just take the time to figure out what really happened on that fateful night 
. Mangione's got a long way to go before he can clear his name, but at least now he's not staring down the barrel of death 
️
i mean what's with all this death penalty drama 
mangione was already a sad dude facing life in prison and now he gets a reprieve 
anyway, this ruling is all about giving mangione a chance to live his best life 
we should be talking about ghost guns and corporate accountability instead of death penalty drama 
And then this judge comes along and basically says "nah, let's just not go there". The case against Mangione still seems pretty flimsy to me, but I guess when it comes down to it, justice has to take precedence. Still can't help but wonder what really went down between Mangione and Brian Thompson...
anyway i think its kinda crazy how Mangione was just walking around with a ghost gun in his backpack and still managed to take down the CEO of a major health insurance company 
i'm just glad he won't have to die for this crime, that would've been devastating 
. The way the media is portraying him as some kind of folk hero who took on the system is pretty cool too 
. It's like he's become a symbol for people who feel like they've been wronged by the system. And you can't deny, the dude was definitely passionate about his cause 
. It's like justice has finally caught up with Mangione and given him a chance to make amends... or at least try to 
️
that's like taking on the system itself! My only concern is what this means for his trial and whether he'll still get a fair shot at defending himself. 
. Newsflash: violence isn't the answer! We need to be having a rational conversation about how to fix our healthcare system, not resorting to vigilante justice. And what about Thompson's family? Don't they deserve closure and justice? It's just so frustrating that Mangione gets to walk free while the truth is twisted to suit his narrative 
.
. Guess you could say justice is a little more nuanced than just black and white right now 
.
.
I think this decision is a mixed bag - on one hand, it's great that Mangione is getting a reprieve from the death penalty, which would've been an extremely harsh punishment, but on the other hand, I'm concerned about the broader implications of his actions and whether they justify the reduced sentence. 
. But I guess when you're accused of killing the CEO of UnitedHealthcare, you've got a lot to lose.
. Like, remember when we used to think it was a good idea to put death penalty on the table for like, every little thing? 