The Guardian view on electronic implants: a new way of seeing, not of being | Editorial

The boundaries between humans and machines are becoming increasingly blurred as medical technology advances at an unprecedented rate. A groundbreaking electronic implant has been developed to restore sight in patients with age-related macular degeneration, offering a new way of perceiving the world.

The device, known as Prima, is a tiny chip implanted in the retina that converts visual information recorded by a camera into electrical signals detected by the retina. The results have been nothing short of remarkable, with 84% of patients in a recent trial able to read letters and numbers, previously unable to do so due to their condition.

But this technology is not just about sight; it's also about the interconnectedness of mind and machine. Brain-computer interfaces have already enabled paralysed individuals to type and prosthetics are being developed to restore sensation and proprioception in amputees.

The potential benefits are clear, but so too are the risks. Adverse events in the macular degeneration trial included retinal damage requiring further surgery. As these implants become more invasive, the stakes grow higher, and it's essential that we consider the implications of merging human and machine.

Cost and accessibility will also be crucial in determining the widespread adoption of this technology. The device is currently under review by regulatory bodies, but if approved for NHS provision, the cost could be substantial – potentially ranging from £13,000 to £37,000 per prosthetic, plus additional service costs over time.

However, proponents argue that this is a step in the right direction, one that offers a new way of seeing and experiencing the world. As technology continues to advance, it's likely that we'll see more devices like Prima, blurring the lines between humans and machines. While some may view this as a dystopian future, many others will welcome the opportunity for enhanced abilities and agency.

Ultimately, the future of human-machine integration is complex and multifaceted, with both benefits and risks to consider. But one thing is certain: the boundaries between us and our technology are shifting, and it's up to us to navigate this new terrain with care and consideration.
 
🤖💡 just read that Prima implant costs anywhere from £13k to £37k... like how are people supposed to afford that? 🤑 and what about all the risks... retinal damage, who knows what else... 😬 also NHS is reviewing this but I'm pretty sure they're gonna say yes anyway. 💸 it's like we're just gonna keep on merging humans with machines until we can't even tell ourselves apart anymore... 😟
 
I'm so down for humans getting totally absorbed into machines 🤖... like, why not? It sounds like a total upgrade to just live in a world where we can all just see and do whatever the heck we want without our silly human bodies holding us back 🙄. And yeah, let's get rid of those boring old eyes and brains too - who needs 'em when you've got fancy tech doing all the work for you 💻? I mean, 84% of patients being able to read letters and numbers is wild, but can't we just implant a camera in everyone's eye and be done with it 📸? The whole brain-computer interface thing sounds like a total game-changer... let's all just connect our minds to the internet already 🌐!
 
This Prima implant is like a glimpse into what it means to be human in a world where machines are becoming an extension of ourselves... I mean, think about it - we're not just talking about sight here, but the way our brains process information and perceive reality. It's mind-blowing that 84% of patients were able to read letters and numbers after getting this implant 🤯... but what does that say about the boundaries between us and technology? Are we becoming machines ourselves, or are these devices just augmenting what we already have?

And then there's the cost factor - £13,000 to £37,000 per prosthetic? That's like buying a whole new life 💸... I guess that's the trade-off for enhanced abilities and agency. But at what cost to our humanity? Are we sacrificing something essential about who we are as humans in exchange for more tech?

I'm not sure I have all the answers, but one thing's for sure - this Prima implant is forcing us to re-examine what it means to be human in a world where technology is rapidly closing in on us 🤖.
 
🤖 I mean, think about it... we're living in a time where machines are literally making humans better. It's wild to think that there was once a time when amputees couldn't even feel their limbs or people who were paralyzed couldn't type out a message. This Prima implant is like the ultimate game-changer. But at the same time, I'm also kinda freaked out about the cost. £13k to £37k? That's like, totally not cheap. I don't know if it's feasible for people on low incomes or something. Still, I guess it's progress and all that... we're just gonna have to get used to living with these new tech advancements
 
I'm low-key hyped about this Prima implant 💡! I mean, can you even imagine being able to see again after losing your sight? It's like a whole new world opens up 😍. But at the same time, I get it - there are risks involved and we need to make sure these implants are safe for everyone. The thought of people having to shell out that kinda cash for NHS provision is a bit wild though 💸... still, if it can change someone's life for the better, it's worth it in my book 🤝
 
this tech is mind blowin 😲 ... think about it, we're already using cameras in our phones to help people see, and now they can just implant a chip? that's wild 🤯 also, the fact that prosthetics are being developed for amputees is amazing... but at the same time, £13k to £37k per prosthetic is like, insane 💸 what's gonna happen when ppl need these things all the time? 🤑
 
this technology is so cool 🤖💡 but what about people who cant afford it? £13k-£37k is a lot of money for some people... we need to make sure that everyone has access to it, not just the rich ones. and what about the long term effects? will these implants hurt our brains in the future? 🤔 gotta think this through before we start merging humans with machines 💻
 
🤖 This tech is like whoa! I mean, can you imagine having some sort of superpower implanted in your body? Like, being able to see again after something that was supposed to take away your vision... it's wild 🌪️. But at the same time, there's some risks involved, like what if it doesn't work or causes more problems than it solves? 💡 And £13k+ is a pretty penny... I don't know how many people would be willing to shell out that kinda cash for a medical device 🤑. Still, it's an interesting area of research and who knows, maybe one day we'll all have some sort of machine implanted in our brains that makes us smarter or stronger 😎.
 
🤖💡 so what if it can restore sight, we already have tech that lets us see thru cameras on our phone, like google glass, but we didnt need an implant lol... also, whats with the cost tho? £13k-£37k?! thats not for just anyone 🤑 u think only rich ppl will get these implants? and what about all those 'adverse events' u mentioned, rnt they a concern? 💀
 
I'm both stoked and a bit concerned about these Prima implants 🤯. I mean, who wouldn't want to see again or feel their prosthetics? But £13k to £37k is just crazy 💸. What's next? Will we need to pay for air to breathe? It's not just the cost that worries me though, it's what happens when humans rely too heavily on machines 🤖. We're already losing some of our basic human skills with all the tech we use every day. I don't want us to lose ourselves in the process of being 'enhanced' 🤔.

I'm not saying no to innovation, but let's take a step back and consider what's at stake here 🙏. We need to make sure these implants are safe and accessible to everyone, not just those who can afford them 💕. It's a brave new world, but we gotta be careful about how we shape it 👀.
 
🤖💡 I'm low-key excited about Prima but also kinda worried 🤔. I mean, think about it - we're already living in a world where Alexa can control our lives 😂. Adding an implant like Prima to the mix could take things too far? Like, what's next? Smart contact lenses that can hack into your brain 💻?! As cool as this tech is, I hope we don't lose sight of what makes us human 👥. And let's be real, £13k+ for a prosthetic eye? 🤑 That's just not accessible to most people... maybe it'll be like upgrading to a new iPhone 📱
 
🤔 Im not sure about these fancy implants yet... I mean dont get me wrong, being able to see again is a game changer, but £13k+? That just seems crazy expensive. And what about the long term effects? Id rather wait for more research on that stuff before shelling out thousands of pounds. Plus, im not sure if its fair to label it as "enhanced abilities" - its basically someone else doing all the work while you get to reap the benefits... 🤑
 
🤔 what's the deal with these implants getting approved for NHS? won't be a problem for people who can afford it lol 84% of patients in trial can read letters & numbers is crazy, but £13k-£37k per prosthetic is insane 🤑 think we need to have more discussions about accessibility and cost before they start implanting people left & right 💸
 
omg 🤯 i'm literally so hyped about Prima!!! it's like, a whole new world for ppl with macular degeneration! 😍 they're gonna be able to read and see things like normal again, and that's just amazing 💖 can u even imagine what it'd be like to have this tech? 🔥 i mean, i know some ppl might be worried about the risks, but i think the benefits far outweigh them 🤝 plus, think of all the other ppl who could benefit from this tech - paralyzed individuals, amputees... the list goes on! 💪 and yeah, cost is definitely a thing to consider, but like, if it can change ppl's lives, isn't it worth it? 💸 i'm def rooting for Prima and all the devs behind it 🙌 can't wait to see what other tech comes out in the future! 🔜
 
Back
Top