For over a decade, US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents have been shooting and killing dozens of people, with not a single agent ever facing criminal charges. The latest incident, in which an ICE agent shot and killed Renee Nicole Good, brings the total number of deaths attributed to ICE shootings to at least 25.
Despite this alarming trend, no federal law enforcement officer or ICE agent has ever been charged with a crime related to such shootings. The reason for this lack of accountability is largely due to the fact that these agents claim they acted in self-defense, and the "reasonableness standard" used by prosecutors is often applied in a way that shields them from liability.
This standard, which holds that an agent's subjective belief that deadly force was necessary to protect themselves or others is enough to justify not charging them with any crime, has been criticized for being overly deferential to law enforcement. Experts argue that this approach can lead to a lack of accountability and transparency in investigations into officer-involved shootings.
Furthermore, ICE agents are largely protected by qualified immunity, a legal doctrine that makes it difficult for individuals to sue federal agents for constitutional violations committed while on the job. This has been reinforced by recent Supreme Court cases, which have further limited the ability of private citizens to bring lawsuits against federal agents.
In the case of Renee Good's death, ICE is claiming that she was involved in an act of "domestic terrorism," a claim that has been disputed by some as unfounded and aimed at deflecting attention from the agent's actions. The fact that the White House and Department of Homeland Security have released conflicting narratives about the incident also highlights the lack of transparency and accountability in these investigations.
The US Attorney General's office, the FBI, and local law enforcement agencies have been criticized for their handling of these cases. In some instances, they have failed to investigate thoroughly or have cleared agents of wrongdoing despite evidence suggesting otherwise.
The pattern of impunity faced by ICE agents has serious implications for public trust in law enforcement and the rule of law. It also highlights the need for greater transparency, accountability, and reform within the US immigration system.
Despite this alarming trend, no federal law enforcement officer or ICE agent has ever been charged with a crime related to such shootings. The reason for this lack of accountability is largely due to the fact that these agents claim they acted in self-defense, and the "reasonableness standard" used by prosecutors is often applied in a way that shields them from liability.
This standard, which holds that an agent's subjective belief that deadly force was necessary to protect themselves or others is enough to justify not charging them with any crime, has been criticized for being overly deferential to law enforcement. Experts argue that this approach can lead to a lack of accountability and transparency in investigations into officer-involved shootings.
Furthermore, ICE agents are largely protected by qualified immunity, a legal doctrine that makes it difficult for individuals to sue federal agents for constitutional violations committed while on the job. This has been reinforced by recent Supreme Court cases, which have further limited the ability of private citizens to bring lawsuits against federal agents.
In the case of Renee Good's death, ICE is claiming that she was involved in an act of "domestic terrorism," a claim that has been disputed by some as unfounded and aimed at deflecting attention from the agent's actions. The fact that the White House and Department of Homeland Security have released conflicting narratives about the incident also highlights the lack of transparency and accountability in these investigations.
The US Attorney General's office, the FBI, and local law enforcement agencies have been criticized for their handling of these cases. In some instances, they have failed to investigate thoroughly or have cleared agents of wrongdoing despite evidence suggesting otherwise.
The pattern of impunity faced by ICE agents has serious implications for public trust in law enforcement and the rule of law. It also highlights the need for greater transparency, accountability, and reform within the US immigration system.
this is wild - no one's ever held accountable for killing dozens of people, and it's all because they claim self-defense 
. I mean, come on! If someone walks up to me with a gun, I'm not gonna start shooting them unless I have to 
. And what's with the "reasonableness standard" that lets agents off scot-free? 
it sounds like a total cop-out. The fact that they're claiming Renee was involved in domestic terrorism is pretty shady too... I don't trust their narrative at all 
. We need to start holding our law enforcement officials accountable for their actions, especially when it comes to situations where force is used. It's time for some real change 
Like what even is going on with these ice agents? They're literally shooting ppl to death & getting away scot free 
The "reasonableness standard" is literally just a way 4 them 2 say whatever they want & walk away with a clean record 
Who else can commit a murder but get in trouble? 
Not to mention the conflicting narratives from the White House & DHS... its like they're tryna cover up what really happened 
And it's not just those ppl, its the whole public trust thing too 
When u see law enforcement gettin away with stuff like this, it makes u question everything 
but at least we're finally talking about it and bringing attention to the systemic issues here its not just about Renee Good's tragic death but also about the larger pattern of impunity faced by ICE agents who clearly need to be held accountable for their actions and the lack of transparency in investigations is just unacceptable 
the reasonableness standard is flawed and qualified immunity needs a major overhaul so that citizens can feel safe reporting any wrongdoing by federal agents its time for real change 
I mean, what kind of system is that supposed to uphold? The fact that everyone's just sweeping these incidents under the rug and not holding anyone accountable is really concerning.
? It's crazy to think that no one has ever faced charges for these shootings - it's like they're above the law 
.
. We need some serious reform in our immigration system ASAP 
!
. And what really gets me is that no one ever holds these guys accountable 
♃️. The reason is always "self-defense" 
! #JusticeForRenee #AccountabilityMatters #ICEReformNow
. And what's up with this "reasonableness standard" that supposedly excuses them from accountability? Sounds like a bunch of cop-out to me 
.
. Anything less is just a slap in the face 
.
.
it's like they're above the law or something. and don't even get me started on the qualified immunity thing... it's just not fair 
. Like, have you guys ever hiked to the top of a mountain and just felt like you're on top of the world? 
It's such a rush! Anyway, back to this ICE thing... I don't know if it's entirely fair to say that they're completely off the hook, but it does seem like they're getting away with some stuff. And can we talk about how weird it is when the White House and DHS are releasing conflicting stories? 
like what even is the point of having laws if you're just gonna let them break 'em? 
and what's with the lack of accountability? 
it's like they're expecting us to just magically know that everything they do is perfect 
i mean, what even is domestic terrorism? sounds like a pretty weak excuse to me 
and all these conflicting narratives from the White House and DHS? 
.