Typeost

Rethinking Navigation

· design

The Lost Art of Navigation: Why We Should Rethink Our Reliance on GPS

As we navigate our daily lives, it’s easy to forget the skills that have been honed over centuries – skills like navigation, map-reading, and wayfinding. With the rise of GPS, we’ve become increasingly reliant on technology to guide us through unfamiliar territories. But what are we sacrificing in this trade-off?

Tara McAndrew, a travel writer who’s made it her mission to ditch the GPS, has been vocal about the dangers of relying too heavily on technology for navigation. Her approach is refreshingly simple: she uses tech for guidance while still exercising her own spatial memory and wayfinding skills.

Research suggests that GPS use can lead to a decline in spatial memory – the brain’s internal map of our surroundings. This is particularly concerning, given that the hippocampus, which is linked to episodic memory and emotional regulation, is also responsible for spatial memory.

The implications are stark: if we continue to rely on GPS without exercising our own wayfinding skills, we risk atrophying the very areas of the brain that help us navigate and remember. Neuroscientist Louisa Dahmani warns that this could lead to a greater risk of Alzheimer’s disease – a chilling reminder of what happens when we neglect the cognitive muscle that underlies our ability to navigate.

To reconnect with the landscape and reclaim these lost skills, Brenda Holder, a Cree traditional knowledge keeper who teaches wayfinding in the Canadian wilderness, offers some sage advice. Her approach is holistic: instead of relying solely on GPS or maps, she encourages people to connect with their surroundings – using natural clues like the position of the sun, stars, and moon, as well as visual landmarks like mountains and rivers.

This is more than just a practical guide; it’s also an invitation to rekindle our relationship with nature. Holder argues that we’ve lost something essential in our increasingly tech-reliant world – a connection to the land itself. By embracing wayfinding and map-reading, we can reconnect with this deeper sense of place and identity.

The limitations of GPS are nothing new; we’ve long known that technology is not infallible. In fact, there’s a growing recognition among authorities that traditional navigation methods – like celestial navigation and LORAN – need to be relearned. As Katherine Dunn points out in her book Little Blue Dot: How GPS Shaped the Modern World, this shift could have significant benefits for our cognitive abilities and our connection to the natural world.

As we continue to rely on GPS without exercising our own wayfinding skills, we risk losing not only our cognitive abilities but also our connection to the natural world. It’s time to rethink our relationship with technology and reclaim these lost arts – for our sake, and that of future generations. By embracing wayfinding and map-reading, we can tap into a rich heritage of exploration and discovery that goes far beyond the confines of our screens. So let’s take a step back from our devices and rediscover the thrill of navigating the world – with our own two feet, our eyes, and our wits about us.

Reader Views

  • TD
    Theo D. · type designer

    The renaissance of traditional navigation skills is long overdue. While I appreciate Tara McAndrew's approach, we must also consider the environmental cost of relying on GPS. The battery-intensive nature of these devices contributes to e-waste and exacerbates our dependence on fossil fuels. Brenda Holder's emphasis on connecting with natural surroundings is crucial, but let's not forget about the infrastructure that facilitates wayfinding - the actual maps themselves. As a type designer, I'm struck by how digital navigation tools often prioritize visual clutter over clarity. A simple reimagining of map design could help bridge the gap between technology and traditional skills, rather than further eroding our cognitive abilities.

  • TS
    The Studio Desk · editorial

    While Tara McAndrew's approach of using GPS for guidance while still developing spatial memory is admirable, we mustn't overlook the nuances of navigation in different environments. The article glosses over the issue of accessibility and social equity – not everyone has equal access to safe outdoor spaces or traditional knowledge keeper training. Furthermore, wayfinding skills can be learned through experience, but they don't necessarily translate to all contexts. For instance, a map-reading skillset developed in urban areas may not serve someone navigating rural terrain with limited infrastructure. The solution lies in acknowledging the complexity of these issues and encouraging inclusive, context-specific approaches to relearning navigation skills.

  • NF
    Noa F. · graphic designer

    It's not just our spatial memory that suffers from excessive GPS use – our appreciation for the natural world also takes a hit. By outsourcing navigation to technology, we're neglecting a crucial aspect of human experience: reading and interpreting environmental cues. The article highlights Brenda Holder's emphasis on using celestial navigation and natural landmarks, but what about the aesthetic value of wayfinding? How do we reconnect with the beauty and complexity of our surroundings when we rely solely on digital maps and coordinates?

Related articles

More from Typeost

View as Web Story →