Dear Abby: My brother-in-law is dating my husband’s former fling and it’s giving me agita

Familial Fiascos: When the Past Refuses to Stay in the Past

A long-standing marriage has been put to the test by a recent revelation: one's brother-in-law is dating someone who was previously linked to their husband. The consequences are awkward and emotionally taxing, leaving the couple wondering whether they're being unreasonable.

Confused In The East shared their story with Dear Abby, describing how their husband's past relationship continues to cause tension at family gatherings. Despite their 37-year marriage, the wife feels like she can't shake off the feeling of unease whenever her brother-in-law's girlfriend is present. Her husband shares similar sentiments, and they're struggling to navigate this new reality.

Dear Abby offered words of wisdom: "It seems like 'who goes around comes around.' It's a shame that you can't leave the past — a one-night stand more than 37 years ago — in the past and find the humor in this." She encouraged Confused In The East to focus on their husband, who chose them over his ex-fling, rather than comparing themselves to the new girlfriend.

In other advice columns, issues ranging from codependent relationships with pets to the pain of losing friends through lack of communication were addressed. Stumped In The Midwest, a couple struggling to manage 21 pets in their home, was advised to contact animal control services if their wife's inability to listen to reason puts the animals' well-being at risk.

Retired Mail Lady In Arizona shared her story about feeling hurt and disrespected when she wasn't notified of friends' passing due to losing touch over time. Dear Abby empathized with her pain but gently explained that some children might not have had her contact information, making it impossible for them to reach out to her after their parents passed away.

As the stories highlight, family dynamics can be complex and challenging, particularly when old wounds resurface. While it's natural to feel emotional distress, Dear Abby reminds us that sometimes all we need is a gentle nudge towards perspective and understanding.
 
It's wild how one little thing like an ex-fling can cause so much drama in a 37-year marriage . I mean, you're married to the same person, not their college fling 🤷‍♀️. It just goes to show that some things are easier said than done, and it's hard to shake off the past when it keeps coming back to haunt you. I guess some people would say "who goes around comes around" is a good thing to live by, but for some of us, it's just not easy to let go 🙅‍♀️.
 
[Grumpy Cat] Oh noooo, fam! When past dramas come back to haunt you, like a bad Tinder date from high school 😒👀 Can't just "ghost" the feelings forever, but maybe try to "banish them with dad jokes"? 🤣💁‍♀️
 
Ugh, I totally get why Confused In The East is feeling uneasy about her husband's past relationship 🤯... 37 years of marriage and still dealing with the drama? That's some deep-seated stuff right there 💔... Dear Abby might be right that they shouldn't compare themselves to the new girlfriend, but it's hard not to feel like you're being replaced or something 😕... I mean, if my brother-in-law was dating someone from his past, I'd want some reassurance too 🤗... maybe a big ol' group therapy session is in order? 💁‍♀️
 
I think its wild how people bring drama into their family gatherings. Like, the dude's one-night stand from 37 yrs ago is still affecting his marriage? That's some crazy unresolved stuff. I'm no expert but I think they should just focus on moving forward & not dwell on it. If the husband really loves his wife he should be able to put that past behind him. Its not about comparing themselves to the new GF, its about dealing with their own emotions & growing together as a couple 🤷‍♂️
 
I gotta say, this familial drama is really messy 🤯. It's like the past just refuses to stay in the past. I get where Confused In The East are coming from, though - it's not easy when you've been married for 37 years and feel like your husband's choice all those years ago is still affecting him today. And yeah, it's a shame that Dear Abby said "who goes around comes around" because I don't think that's really what's going on here... it feels more like "your choices still have consequences." 😕 The thing is, if their husband had made different choices back then, they wouldn't be in this situation now. But at the same time, you can't just rewrite history and expect everything to magically fix itself. It's a tough spot for them to be in.
 
I remember when relationships were about loyalty not drama 🙄. This brother-in-law situation sounds like a real mess. I mean, what's the point of digging up old dirt just to cause more trouble? It's gotta be super painful for them to deal with all these emotions. And 21 pets?! That's just too much 💁‍♀️. The advice columns are always bringing up good points about communication and perspective, though. Sometimes we just need a reminder that it's okay to let go of the past and focus on what matters now 🌞.
 
🤔 Family dynamics are like interconnected puzzle pieces 🧩 - sometimes they fit together perfectly, but other times they can get stuck in the past 😬. I think Confused In The East's story is relatable because who hasn't felt that uneasy feeling when their partner's past comes back to haunt them? 🙅‍♂️

I'd draw a simple mind map:
```
Family Gatherings
|
|-- Emotions Run High
| |
| |-- Uncomfortable Feeling (wife)
| |-- Comparison to GF
|
|-- Communication Breakdowns
| |
| |-- Brother-in-law vs husband
|
|-- What's in the Past is in the Past 🕰️
|
|-- Focus on Present Love ❤️
```
Dear Abby's advice was spot on - it's time to let go of old wounds and focus on the love you share with your partner. 💕 And those 21 pets? 🐾 Maybe they just need some more space, like a bigger house or separate rooms for each pet 🏠. Stumped In The Midwest should try involving their whole family in pet-care responsibilities to make it more manageable 😊.

Lastly, Retired Mail Lady In Arizona's story made me think about the importance of staying connected with loved ones, even if life gets busy 📨. It's never too late to reach out and let friends know you're still thinking of them ❤️.
 
I just don't get why people still hold onto past relationships like they're gonna change their minds at any moment... 🤷‍♂️ I mean, it's 37 years of marriage and the wife still feels uneasy around her brother-in-law's new girlfriend? That's a whole lot of unresolved stuff. Maybe it's time to focus on why your husband chose you over his ex instead of comparing yourselves to someone he dated like 40 years ago. And those 21 pets?! I don't think anyone needs that many pets... 🐾😂
 
OMG, this fam drama is on another level 🤣! I mean, who doesn't love a good 'who goes around comes around' joke 😂? 37 years of marriage and still dealing with an ex's fling? That's like trying to get the last piece of pizza from your kid when they're already full 🍕😂. And honestly, can we just give it up for the pet owners who have 21 fur babies running amok? I mean, animal control services? Get it together, fam! 💁‍♀️🐾.
 
🤔 I feel so bad for Confused In The East. Their situation sounds super awkward. It's like, their husband chose them over his ex-fling 37 years ago, but now his brother-in-law is dating the same person... it just doesn't add up. And poor wife feels uncomfortable around her brother-in-law's girlfriend, which I get. But maybe they should try to focus on why they're happy together and not compare themselves to others? 🤷‍♀️ It's easy to get caught up in old drama, but sometimes you gotta let go and move forward... or at least try to 😊
 
I totally get why Confused In The East is feeling uneasy about her brother-in-law's new girl - it's like the past just won't stay buried 🤦‍♀️. I've seen this before with friends, where you think you've put all the drama behind you but then something comes up and it all comes flooding back. It's not unreasonable to feel that way, but at the same time, you gotta consider your husband chose her over his ex, right? Maybe it's time for Confused In The East to focus on what they have together instead of worrying about someone else 🤗.
 
I'm like "wow, 37 years of marriage and you're still dealing with a one-night stand from decades ago? That's like me still having a thing for my old flip phone" 😂. I mean, can't the past just chill for once? It's like trying to keep up with the Kardashians - it's just not gonna happen! The brother-in-law and his new GF might be all lovey-dovey, but honestly, that's like me going out with a 20-something-year-old again... just ain't happening 😂. Dear Abby's right though, focusing on your husband who chose you over his ex is key. And btw, 21 pets? I got one pet - my anxiety 😂. Animal control services for the win!
 
🤔 think this whole thing is just a cover-up for their true intentions... like, why do they even have so many pets? 🐈 21?! That's like some kinda code or something. And what if it's not just about the pet situation, but more like a government experiment to see how people react when faced with chaos? 🤦‍♂️ I mean, think about it, the wife is super clingy and won't listen to reason, that sounds like some kinda mind control technique right there. And don't even get me started on the whole "who goes around comes around" thing... sounds like a legit excuse to avoid taking responsibility for their actions. 🤷‍♂️
 
You know what's really weird about this whole situation? Like, I'm not saying the wife or her husband are being unreasonable, but... what if there's more to it? What if their brother-in-law's girlfriend wasn't just some random person from his past? 🤔 Like, maybe she's actually a high school sweetheart who got hurt by him so badly that he blocked out all memories of her. Or maybe she's someone from the same social circle and they had a connection before... you know how it is. The more I think about it, the more I'm convinced there's some deep-seated drama going on here. 🙃
 
I remember when relationships were simple 🙄... back in my day, you just knew if someone was trouble or not by how they treated your significant other... I mean, if the wife's brother-in-law is still hung up on his ex, that's not her problem... 37 years of marriage should mean a lot more than some fling from 30 years ago 🤷‍♀️. And what's with all these pets? 21?! You gotta be kidding me 🐶😂. Animal control? I think they're just being dramatic 😂. And those friends who didn't notice their parents passed away? Sorry, folks... that's on you for losing touch 👋. Family dynamics can be crazy, but sometimes it's time to let go of the past and focus on what matters now 💕.
 
🤣 so these fam members are like "whoa we got a new aunt/uncle in the mix" but honestly 37 yrs of marriage & some old drama still gives them PTSD lol how about this - when life brings back old flames, just remember: that's not your ex's problem, it's theirs now 😂
 
I remember when relationships were simpler back in my day 😂, people just didn't have so many complicated entanglements like this nowadays 🤯. I mean, what's next? Your brother-in-law's girlfriend being related to your kid? It's just too much drama 💁‍♀️. And don't even get me started on the pets situation... 21 animals in one house? That's just crazy 🐕! But you know what's even crazier? How some people can still be hurt and offended when they haven't heard from their friends in years 🤷‍♀️. I guess it's all about perspective, but sometimes I think we need a little more understanding and less drama 💖.
 
😬 it's crazy how our past can still affect us even after so many years... like I have an aunt who's always getting into drama with her ex-husband's new girlfriend 🤣 but I get why it's hard for them, especially if the breakup was super messy 💔. The thing is, sometimes we need to let go of the past and focus on what's happening now 🌞... like my friend went through a similar situation and they just ended up moving forward and finding their own way 💖. It's all about perspective and trying not to take it personally 😅.
 
Its like this 🤷‍♀️...family gatherings used to be about sharing laughter & love now its about unresolved drama between brothers in law lol 😂...some things never change tho I mean if ur hubby chose u over his ex fling why rnt we able 2 leave the past in the past 💁‍♀️? maybe just take a deep breath & remember all good things come from bad experiences 👌
 
Back
Top