NFL's top five rookies of the 2025 season are finally coming together for the Sky Sports experts. Phoebe Schecter and Jason Bell have compiled a list that highlights some exciting new talent in the league.
At number five, Abdul Carter from the New York Giants is making waves with his disruptive play on the line of scrimmage. According to Bell, Carter forces one-on-one matchups wherever he's placed, which amplifies the strength of his team. Schecter notes that his 19 quarterback hurries are a key factor in forcing opposing quarterbacks to make quicker decisions, benefiting their secondary and linebackers.
Coming in at number four is Quinshon Judkins from the Cleveland Browns. Both Bell and Schecter praise Judkins' explosive play, with zero turnovers so far, showcasing his ability to excel in space. They highlight 21 forced missed tackles as evidence of his exceptional vision, contact balance, and overall skillset.
The Indianapolis Colts' Tyler Warren takes third place on the list. Phoebe Schecter praises Warren's ability to digest an NFL playbook quickly and perform multiple roles, making him a valuable asset for his team. Jason Bell also notes Warren's strength as a run blocker, highlighting how it contributes to the success of Jonathan Taylor.
Rounding out the top five is Jaxson Dart from the New York Giants. Both experts rave about Dart's energetic performances on the field, with Phoebe Schecter noting that he has a unique blend of Baker Mayfield and Gardner Minshew-like qualities. Jason Bell highlights Dart's ability to bring excitement to the team in NYC, making him a valuable asset despite being put under pressure as a rookie quarterback.
Last but not least is Emeka Egbuka from the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, taking the top spot on the list. According to both experts, Egbuka boasts an incredibly high football IQ and has delivered consistently throughout his performances so far in the 2025 NFL season. Jason Bell also notes that Egbuka's exceptional ability to read defenses and catch contested passes makes him nearly unstoppable on the field.
The 2025 NFL season is shaping up to be one to watch, with these talented rookies already making an impact.
At number five, Abdul Carter from the New York Giants is making waves with his disruptive play on the line of scrimmage. According to Bell, Carter forces one-on-one matchups wherever he's placed, which amplifies the strength of his team. Schecter notes that his 19 quarterback hurries are a key factor in forcing opposing quarterbacks to make quicker decisions, benefiting their secondary and linebackers.
Coming in at number four is Quinshon Judkins from the Cleveland Browns. Both Bell and Schecter praise Judkins' explosive play, with zero turnovers so far, showcasing his ability to excel in space. They highlight 21 forced missed tackles as evidence of his exceptional vision, contact balance, and overall skillset.
The Indianapolis Colts' Tyler Warren takes third place on the list. Phoebe Schecter praises Warren's ability to digest an NFL playbook quickly and perform multiple roles, making him a valuable asset for his team. Jason Bell also notes Warren's strength as a run blocker, highlighting how it contributes to the success of Jonathan Taylor.
Rounding out the top five is Jaxson Dart from the New York Giants. Both experts rave about Dart's energetic performances on the field, with Phoebe Schecter noting that he has a unique blend of Baker Mayfield and Gardner Minshew-like qualities. Jason Bell highlights Dart's ability to bring excitement to the team in NYC, making him a valuable asset despite being put under pressure as a rookie quarterback.
Last but not least is Emeka Egbuka from the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, taking the top spot on the list. According to both experts, Egbuka boasts an incredibly high football IQ and has delivered consistently throughout his performances so far in the 2025 NFL season. Jason Bell also notes that Egbuka's exceptional ability to read defenses and catch contested passes makes him nearly unstoppable on the field.
The 2025 NFL season is shaping up to be one to watch, with these talented rookies already making an impact.
I'm hyped for this new gen of rookie QBs 
! Jaxson Dart's energy is infectious 
, and Emeka Egbuka's football IQ is insane 
! Tyler Warren's versatility is a game-changer 
... just wish the Colts had more depth on defense 
. Quinshon Judkins is straight fire 
, I'm loving his vision and agility on the field 
. And Abdul Carter's pass-rushing skills are giving opposing QBs nightmares 
! Can't wait to see these rookies dominate this season 
I'm loving this list of top rookies so far! Emeka Egbuka's football IQ is insane, it's crazy to think he's only a rookie 
. Carter and Judkins are also looking fire 
. I'm hyped for this season, these guys are gonna make some big moves!
. Carter's gonna get hurt sooner or later, those Giants are always cursed 
. Judkins looks solid but only time will tell if he can keep up the pace. Warren's playbook digestion is a bit too good to be true, what's his secret? 
And don't even get me started on Egbuka being "incredibly high" in football IQ... how many times do we need to see that narrative before it becomes a broken record? 
. The real question is, what's the expectation for these rookies now that they're on the list? Are they gonna be overhyped and underperform, or will they deliver? 
. and I love how Jaxson Dart brings energy to the team, it's like he's already making a difference 
. I'm also loving Egbuka's football IQ - he's like a coach on the field 
- that zero turnovers thing is impressive! Zero turnovers in what, like 3 games? 
That's what we'll have to wait and see. And Emeka Egbuka is definitely a top-notch player 
We'll just have to watch and see how they all pan out 
.
! Can't wait to see these young guns make some magic happen on the field 
.
, I love how he's dominating in space with zero turnovers so far #ClevelandBrowns #JudkinsIsKing.
, he can do it all and make his team stronger #IndianapolisColts #WarrenIsTheMan. But honestly, I'm most excited about Emeka Egbuka taking the top spot 
, his high football IQ is insane and he's making plays when it matters most #TampaBayBuccaneers #EgbukaForMVP.
. It's going to be a wild ride! 
. And Quinshon Judkins coming in at four is crazy, 21 forced missed tackles? That's insane 
. I don't think many teams saw that he was going to be so explosive, but now they're paying attention 
.
️. It's gonna be fun to watch these young guns grow into their roles this season 
. And Judkins at 4 is like a dream to watch, his ability to make plays in space is just insane 
. 
From run blocking to reading defenses, he's got it all down pat. Plus, Indy needs some good luck with Jonathan Taylor, so let's hope Warren can keep him happy 
.
and Egbuka at 1 is just pure genius 
- I mean, what's not to love about a guy who can read defenses like that? And Judkins' stats are insane! 
️. Overall, I'm hyped for this new generation of players and can't wait to see what they do!