Tensions flared at Chicago's annual "Christmas Tree Ship" charity event Saturday as Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem's presence sparked protests, with demonstrators calling for her to leave. The usually festive occasion, which has taken place annually since 1996, was marked by a stark contrast between the holiday cheer and the heated anti-Noem sentiments.
Noem, who is overseeing President Donald Trump's mass deportations, was met with opposition from dozens of protesters gathered outside Navy Pier where the event was held. The Secretary expressed gratitude to the Coast Guard for operating under her department, while also stating her hope that people would "recognize that we're bringing them news of happiness and peace." However, chants of "Kristi Noem go home" could be heard from protesters on the other side of the park.
Chicago Police officers intervened, moving protesters away from the event's venue to prevent any potential disruptions. Susan Jobst, a volunteer who has been participating in the Christmas Tree Ship effort for six years, expressed her surprise at seeing protests at the typically joyful event, saying there is "a time and place for protesting and this isn’t it."
Critics like Michael Aaron of Indivisible Chicago Alliance have been vocal about Noem's administration's immigration policies. In light of recent actions in Charlotte and New Orleans, where DHS enforcement efforts ramped up, Aaron sees Noem's appearance as an attempt to associate herself with the positive aspects of community service while ignoring her department's role in mass deportations.
It is worth noting that despite concerns about mass arrests during Trump-era immigration enforcement campaigns, such as a recent raid on an Elgin home in which federal agents deployed helicopters and bright lights, many families continue to benefit from the annual event. This year, over 1,200 Christmas trees were delivered to Chicago for local charities, supporting more than 1,000 families.
While this year's event has brought attention to the complexities surrounding immigration policy under Noem's leadership, it also underscores the community's continued commitment to providing aid and support during the holiday season.
Noem, who is overseeing President Donald Trump's mass deportations, was met with opposition from dozens of protesters gathered outside Navy Pier where the event was held. The Secretary expressed gratitude to the Coast Guard for operating under her department, while also stating her hope that people would "recognize that we're bringing them news of happiness and peace." However, chants of "Kristi Noem go home" could be heard from protesters on the other side of the park.
Chicago Police officers intervened, moving protesters away from the event's venue to prevent any potential disruptions. Susan Jobst, a volunteer who has been participating in the Christmas Tree Ship effort for six years, expressed her surprise at seeing protests at the typically joyful event, saying there is "a time and place for protesting and this isn’t it."
Critics like Michael Aaron of Indivisible Chicago Alliance have been vocal about Noem's administration's immigration policies. In light of recent actions in Charlotte and New Orleans, where DHS enforcement efforts ramped up, Aaron sees Noem's appearance as an attempt to associate herself with the positive aspects of community service while ignoring her department's role in mass deportations.
It is worth noting that despite concerns about mass arrests during Trump-era immigration enforcement campaigns, such as a recent raid on an Elgin home in which federal agents deployed helicopters and bright lights, many families continue to benefit from the annual event. This year, over 1,200 Christmas trees were delivered to Chicago for local charities, supporting more than 1,000 families.
While this year's event has brought attention to the complexities surrounding immigration policy under Noem's leadership, it also underscores the community's continued commitment to providing aid and support during the holiday season.
man I remember when Trump didn't have all these deportations going on... it feels like we're back in Obama's days 
and everyone's so divided about immigration 
it's sad to see people protesting at something that's supposed to bring happiness during the holidays. I mean, 1k+ families got Christmas trees this year 
and that's what matters most. Maybe Noem should just stick to the Coast Guard part of her job 
that's not exactly what most ppl would call "happiness and peace" 
plus its chicago in december... the last thing ppl need is more drama on christmas 
but at the same time, you cant just ignore all these concerns about mass arrests and deportations 
maybe noem should just stick to the event and not bring that baggage with her 
... I mean, I get that people are passionate about their opinions, but can't we all just come together for a good cause? The Christmas Tree Ship event is such an amazing thing, bringing so much joy to families in need. And now, it's being overshadowed by politics 
... let's keep that positivity alive! 
, can't believe protests broke out at a charity event! Interesting how people are calling for her to leave, even though she seems to be trying to bring some positivity... but still, her policies are pretty divisive 
.
i mean we need ppl to speak out against these deportation policies but can't they just do it at a different time? like maybe not when hundreds of families are actually getting help?! 
. I mean, I get why some folks are upset about Kristi Noem's deportation policies and all, but do they really need to protest it in front of a bunch of people trying to spread holiday cheer? 
Anyway, I do think it's great to see so many families benefiting from this event - it's definitely a reminder of the importance of community and kindness during the holiday season. 
. According to Gallup's 2022 data, only 27% of Americans approve of Trump's immigration policies 
. The Coast Guard's stats show they've assisted over 1.3 million people between FY 2017 and FY 2022 
. So yeah, it's all about context, right? 
.
.
.
.
Please. The chants of "Kristi Noem go home" were so justified 
like, let everyone have their own thing, you feel?