When Jodie Foster joined the cast of True Detective's fourth season as Chief Liz Danvers, many assumed her character would be gay. The show's initial teaser trailer hinted at a potential queer connection between Danvers and Trooper Evangeline Navarro, played by Kali Reis. However, the first episode took an unexpected turn when Danvers had matter-of-fact sex with Captain Ted Connelly, played by Christopher Eccleston, leaving fans stunned.
The backlash was swift and merciless. Fans of the show felt betrayed, while others expressed outrage on social media, with some even review-bombing the season on Rotten Tomatoes. Showrunner Issa López later responded to the criticism, stating that "bros and hardcore fanboys" from earlier seasons were responsible for dragging down the audience score.
The decision to make Danvers' character straight appears to have been driven by fear of low ratings. In a 2023 interview with Vanity Fair, López revealed that in an initial draft, Foster's and Reis' characters were intended to be gay, but that changed when it became clear that audiences were hesitant to accept queer representation.
The shift away from queer subtext is particularly telling, given the show's earlier seasons, which explored themes of trauma, identity, and human connection. It seems that HBO and López felt pressure to appease a more conservative audience, sacrificing queer representation in the process.
As Kali Reis noted, "If they could just get their heads out of season one's ass," it would be better for the show. However, instead of embracing the complexity and nuance of queer relationships, True Detective: Night Country opted for a more conventional narrative. The result is a show that feels forced to conform to straight heteronormative expectations, sacrificing its potential as a thought-provoking exploration of human connection.
Ultimately, this decision raises questions about the role of representation in television and the impact it can have on audiences. By prioritizing ratings over queer subtext, True Detective: Night Country risks alienating fans who crave more authentic and nuanced portrayals of LGBTQIA characters.
The backlash was swift and merciless. Fans of the show felt betrayed, while others expressed outrage on social media, with some even review-bombing the season on Rotten Tomatoes. Showrunner Issa López later responded to the criticism, stating that "bros and hardcore fanboys" from earlier seasons were responsible for dragging down the audience score.
The decision to make Danvers' character straight appears to have been driven by fear of low ratings. In a 2023 interview with Vanity Fair, López revealed that in an initial draft, Foster's and Reis' characters were intended to be gay, but that changed when it became clear that audiences were hesitant to accept queer representation.
The shift away from queer subtext is particularly telling, given the show's earlier seasons, which explored themes of trauma, identity, and human connection. It seems that HBO and López felt pressure to appease a more conservative audience, sacrificing queer representation in the process.
As Kali Reis noted, "If they could just get their heads out of season one's ass," it would be better for the show. However, instead of embracing the complexity and nuance of queer relationships, True Detective: Night Country opted for a more conventional narrative. The result is a show that feels forced to conform to straight heteronormative expectations, sacrificing its potential as a thought-provoking exploration of human connection.
Ultimately, this decision raises questions about the role of representation in television and the impact it can have on audiences. By prioritizing ratings over queer subtext, True Detective: Night Country risks alienating fans who crave more authentic and nuanced portrayals of LGBTQIA characters.
. They had the perfect opportunity to create a compelling story around Jodie Foster's character, Danvers, being queer or having a queer connection with her partner. But instead, they decided to go for a more conventional route because of ratings pressure? It's like, what happened to taking risks and pushing boundaries in storytelling? 
. It's like, there are legitimate concerns about representation in TV, but instead of addressing those concerns, we get deflection and blame-shifting.
.
. I mean, I love Jodie Foster as an actress, but this decision feels like a cop-out to me. The whole thing with the teaser trailer was so promising 
. I can see why fans would get upset, especially after seasons one and two were all about exploring trauma and identity. It's like they took a step back from that complex stuff for the sake of appeasing a more conservative audience 
. I'm disappointed in HBO for putting ratings over representation. We need shows that take risks and push boundaries, you know? 
But, honestly, I'm kinda disappointed too 
Maybe the show would've been even more impactful and thought-provoking as a result? The thing that bothers me is that it feels forced - like they're trying to fit into a certain mold rather than embracing the complexity of human connection. 
Still, I love Jodie Foster and Kali Reis, and I'll still watch the season with an open mind 
I'm so done with TV shows trying to appease everyone by dumbing down their storylines just to get a higher rating 
. Like, come on HBO! You guys know you're capable of creating something really deep and thought-provoking. Instead, you decide to hold back on the queer representation because it's "too much" for some viewers? That's just lazy 
. I mean, what does that say about your vision as a showrunner? Do you really think queerness is something to be feared or shied away from? 
.
. I mean, I know there's a lot of pressure to keep viewership up, but it feels like HBO was too afraid to take a chance on queer representation again after the buzz around season 1. It's like they thought, "Oh no, if we do this, people will leave us for shows that actually represent LGBTQIA characters." 
Newsflash: there are already so many amazing shows doing it right! The complexity and nuance of queer relationships is what makes True Detective so great in the first place. By watering it down, they're losing sight of what made the show special in the first place. Let's hope next season gets a second chance to get back on track 
.
. Now, fans feel like the show is being forced to conform to straight heteronormative expectations, which is a shame because that's exactly what made seasons 1 and 2 so great