‘Wicked’ American Girl dolls are the hottest holiday toy of 2025 — as desperate fans pay $2K on eBay

American Girl's "Wicked" Dolls Cast a Spell on Desperate Buyers

This holiday season, a new spell has been cast over American Girl enthusiasts – one of desire, desperation, and dollars. The company's limited-edition "tinge" Collector Series dolls, featuring glammed-up Glinda and green-washed Elphaba, have emerged as the hottest toy of 2025.

Just ahead of the blockbuster sequel "Wicked: For Good," which hit US theaters on November 21, these dolls quietly appeared on store shelves and quickly sold out. Desperate fans then flocked to resale sites, where listings for Elphaba are now soaring to a staggering $999. The high price tag has left many struggling to afford the luxury item.

While children may have been the initial target audience for the doll's design, it appears that grown-up collectors are driving the demand. These adult enthusiasts are flaunting their coveted collectibles on social media platforms like TikTok, showcasing their magical hauls with gleeful abandon.

One fan, @katnisseverslay, captioned a video of herself twirling around with her Glinda doll, boasting about her $300 purchase. Another collector, @carladistefano30, shared a video of herself toting her Elphaba from the kitchen to the backyard, poking fun at her obsession over the expensive toy.

However, not everyone is enamored with the dolls' high price tags. Some viewers have expressed sticker shock and concern about the financial burden imposed by these luxury items. "I can't even afford rent, I don't see how people are out here buying $300 dollar American dolls," one user wrote.

The rarity of the dolls, combined with their nostalgic value, has fueled the frenzy. Only 6,800 Glinda dolls and 6,000 Elphaba dolls were produced, making them highly sought after by collectors. Even sleepover-ready pajama sets for the dolls are commanding high prices on eBay, ranging from $199 to $295.

As the demand for these luxury items continues to soar, it's clear that nostalgia plays a significant role in their appeal. For many adults, revisiting childhood favorites has become an exciting experience. However, the exorbitant price tags have raised concerns about the financial implications of this trend.

Ultimately, American Girl's "Wicked" dolls have cast a spell on buyers' wallets – one that may not be easily broken.
 
I just saw this news and I'm like "seriously? $999 for a doll?" 🤯 I mean, I get it, collectibles are cool and all, but come on! 😂 Kids aren't even the target audience anymore, it's like grown-ups who still have a crush on their childhood faves. It's kinda weird that people are flaunting these pricey toys on social media too... like, hello? 📸 I don't blame those who can't afford them, though - $300 for a doll is just crazy! 💸
 
I'm so down with these new Wicked dolls being all the rage 🤩... I mean, I've seen some pics and they're pretty cool, but $999 for an Elphaba doll? That's just crazy expensive 💸. Like, I get that it's a limited edition and nostalgic, but do we really need to break the bank over a toy? 😂 On the other hand, if I were a huge Wicked fan and wanted to showcase my love for the series on social media, maybe paying $300 for a Glinda doll wouldn't be so bad... unless it's just me collecting dust in my room with a bunch of useless junk 🤦‍♂️. The resale prices are wild, though - I wonder if those sellers are making enough to make it worth the hassle? 🤑
 
🤑 $300+ for a doll? crazy! I get why some people want to collect them, but come on... it's just a toy! 🤷‍♀️ and now they're selling them online for ridiculous prices? what's next? 💸 $1k+ for a stuffed animal or something? 🐻🤑 I'm good with my old toys from childhood, no need to break the bank. And can we talk about the environment? all these packaging and shipping costs are probably harming the planet 🌎💔
 
ugh I don't get why people are so desperate for these dolls they're just toys lol🤣 and $999 is ridiculous I remember when Beanie Babies were all the rage back in 2000 and those things cost like $5 each now I'm starting to think it's just a marketing ploy to make money off nostalgic adults 🤑 anyone else thinking this is getting out of hand?
 
omg u guys can u believe these american girl dolls r selling 4 like $300-$999?? i remember getting those wicked dolls for kids back in the day & now they're selling them 2 grown adults 4 absurd prices lol what's next gonna b a vintage teddy bear collector set 4 like $10k?? anyway i guess it's cool that collectors are having fun with them but seriously who can afford that kinda cash?
 
I get why these dolls are so popular, especially with the movie coming out 🎥. The glammed-up designs and nostalgic value are definitely drawing in fans. But $999 for an Elphaba doll? That's just crazy 💸. I'm all about supporting small businesses and buying things that bring joy to your life, but this is getting ridiculous. And what's the resale market like? It feels like people are more worried about getting their hands on these dolls than enjoying them in the first place 😐. Still, I can see why collectors are so into it - those dolls do look amazing, even if they're a bit overpriced 🤑.
 
I'm telling ya, this doll craze is like a perfect storm of consumerism and supply & demand 🌪️. I mean, think about it, the company creates these limited-edition dolls, knowing they're going to sell out fast, and then prices skyrocket because people can't get their hands on 'em. It's like a game of financial hot potato 🍃.

And don't even get me started on the resale sites 🤯. I mean, come on, $999 for an Elphaba doll? That's just plain crazy 💸. Meanwhile, our politicians are still struggling to make ends meet, and these adults are throwing their money at a toy like it's going out of style 🤑.

It's like we're living in a world where nostalgia is a luxury that only the wealthy can afford 🎁. And what about the rest of us? Are we just expected to be left behind while our dollars get cast into the spellbook of American Girl's doll empire 🔮?
 
I'm low-key bummed that people are shelling out that kinda cash for these dolls 🤑💸. Like, what's the point of spending all that money on something that's just gonna collect dust? And it's not like the dolls themselves are even that special – I mean, they're still just inanimate objects 😒.

And don't even get me started on how it's affecting younger collectors who can't afford to join in on the fun 🤷‍♀️. It's just not fair that some people have more money to splurge than others.

Plus, it's kinda sad that these dolls are becoming a status symbol or something 💔. I mean, shouldn't we be focusing on what really matters, like actual accomplishments and experiences? Not just flaunting our wallets 🤑.
 
ugh i'm so tired of these limited-edition releases always causing such a frenzy 🙄 they're just dollies! people need to chill out & remember what's really important, like actual relationships with friends & family, not some plastic toy 💸 meanwhile i'm over here buying a used bookshelf for $100 instead of paying top dollar for an overpriced american girl doll 📚👎
 
omg I mean, who needs to pay 300 bucks for an American Girl doll lol 🤣👠 it's like they're trying to cast a spell of broke on people's wallets. and can we talk about how desperate buyers are on resale sites? $999 for Elphaba? that's just crazy 💸 I mean, I get the nostalgia thing, but come on, it's just a doll 🧙‍♀️👑
 
Back
Top