Bataclan Attack Drama Sparks Debate Over Filming Location: Director Rejects Accusations of 'Indecency'
The director of the upcoming TV mini-series "Des Vivants" about survivors of the 2015 Bataclan terrorist attack, Jean-Xavier de Lestrade, has rejected accusations that filming inside the theatre was "indecent".
Lestrade's decision to film at the actual site of the attack has sparked controversy among some survivors and bereaved families, who claim it blurred the lines between fiction and reality. Arthur Dénouveaux, the president of Life for Paris association representing many survivors, argued that filming in the theatre would "upset survivors and bereaved families".
However, Lestrade maintained that the seven survivors he interviewed wanted their ordeal recreated inside the building. He stated that it was a crucial aspect to accurately portray the event. The director acknowledged it was not an easy choice but said they were telling the precise story of these survivors.
Lestrade emphasized that the production team failed to get permission to film inside the theatre, and the Bataclan management agreed only after the hostages wrote a joint letter requesting authorization.
Not everyone is opposed to filming at the site. Philippe Duperron, the president of 13onze15 victims' association, met with Lestrade and appreciated his work on "Des Vivants". He noted that there are mixed views among survivors and bereaved families but believes most would not be scandalized or revolted by the decision to film at the actual site.
The director of the upcoming TV mini-series "Des Vivants" about survivors of the 2015 Bataclan terrorist attack, Jean-Xavier de Lestrade, has rejected accusations that filming inside the theatre was "indecent".
Lestrade's decision to film at the actual site of the attack has sparked controversy among some survivors and bereaved families, who claim it blurred the lines between fiction and reality. Arthur Dénouveaux, the president of Life for Paris association representing many survivors, argued that filming in the theatre would "upset survivors and bereaved families".
However, Lestrade maintained that the seven survivors he interviewed wanted their ordeal recreated inside the building. He stated that it was a crucial aspect to accurately portray the event. The director acknowledged it was not an easy choice but said they were telling the precise story of these survivors.
Lestrade emphasized that the production team failed to get permission to film inside the theatre, and the Bataclan management agreed only after the hostages wrote a joint letter requesting authorization.
Not everyone is opposed to filming at the site. Philippe Duperron, the president of 13onze15 victims' association, met with Lestrade and appreciated his work on "Des Vivants". He noted that there are mixed views among survivors and bereaved families but believes most would not be scandalized or revolted by the decision to film at the actual site.
, to be honest. I think it's a bit dramatic when some people get upset about filming in the theatre. Like, we're talking about a real-life event here that had such a profound impact on people's lives... but at the same time, this is a TV show, not a documentary 
. If the survivors themselves are cool with it and feel it helps tell their story, then why should others get worked up? It's all about balance, right? I mean, if nothing else, it might spark some much-needed conversations about the Bataclan attack 
.
the drama surrounding filming at bataclan tho is crazy!! 
i totally get why some ppl are upset but like jean-xavier de lestrade said it was actually a request from 7 survivors to recreate their experience in the theatre which is SO important for accuracy 
and btw they didnt even get permission to film there lol the bataclan management agreed after the hostages wrote a joint letter requesting authorization...i guess its all about perspective 
can't wait for this show to come out! 
. If seven of them wanted their story recreated in the actual place where it went down, how can that be indecent? 
Don't get me wrong, I'm all for respecting everyone's feelings, but if the people involved really want to tell this story, why not film at the site? It seems like a way to show the true impact of what happened on those who were there 
.
. If the survivors who were there wanted their story told in such a way, that's all that matters. But at the same time, I can see how it might be jarring for others to see the theatre where those tragic events happened used as a set. Can't we just have a nuanced conversation about this instead of tearing each other apart? 
. director dude said he got permission & that survivors wanted to reenact it 4 accuracy...i dont no what 2 think tho 
. But at the same time, I can understand why some people might be upset - it's not like they're exploiting the tragedy for ratings or something 
. The fact that there are mixed views among survivors and bereaved families just shows how complex this issue is 
. Maybe we'll see a documentary-style approach to filming instead? 
... As a survivor of a different tragedy (not related to Bataclan) I know how hard it is to see that place again after everything you've been through 
. I'm not sure what's more cringeworthy, the lack of consent or the 'artistic vision' behind this whole thing 
I can see how some people might be upset but for every person who's freaking out, there's another one who's actually proud of him for telling this story honestly and respectfully. The production team should get major props for doing their research and getting permission from the right people too 
.
. I can understand why - it's like they're reliving the trauma again. But on the other hand, if these seven survivors wanted to be part of it, that's gotta count for something 
. Guess you just gotta respect everyone's opinions and move forward